TrendCrypt News

Senate Passes DEATH BETS Act. What Counts as a Bet on Death?

A Kalshi trader says he got 29 cents per contract after Iran’s leader died. A Senate bill asks whether a death was expected to decide the market from day one.

Published 2026-11-21
Updated 2026-11-21
Publisher Ananthi Reeta
Senate Passes DEATH BETS Act. What Counts as a Bet on Death?

Itay Golan bought 1,436 contracts on Kalshi that asked whether Ali Khamenei would be out as Iran’s supreme leader before April 1. Khamenei died in February. Golan expected a dollar for every Yes contract he held. In his court complaint, he said the exchange credited him with 29 cents apiece.

That gap helps explain the DEATH BETS Act, which the U.S. Senate passed on November 19. The bill would bar federally registered markets from offering certain contracts on war and death. For a market phrased as a question about someone leaving office, the decisive issue would be what an exchange could reasonably expect when it first listed the contract. Was the person’s death the main event likely to decide the result? As of November 21, the bill still needed House action.

Key Takeaways

  • The Senate passed S. 4035 by voice vote after adopting an amendment. The November text differs in important ways from the bill introduced in March.
  • One provision covers event contracts that explicitly reference terrorism, assassination, war or U.S. military operations. Another looks at how an individual’s death is expected to determine the outcome.
  • The proposed restrictions apply to listing and clearing contracts. The bill gives exchanges no formula for paying people who already hold a position.
  • Sports contracts have their own legal fight. The sponsors wrote the amendment to leave open whether federal law overrides state rules on sports betting.

What the Senate would ask an exchange to decide

A prediction market turns a question into something people can trade. On a typical binary contract, a winning share pays a dollar and a losing share pays zero. The price can move throughout the day. The exchange eventually determines which outcome occurred under the terms it published. Those terms can include an exception that pays an amount between zero and a dollar.

The DEATH BETS Act intervenes earlier in the life of a market. If enacted in the Senate’s form, it would prohibit a registered entity from listing a covered contract for trading or accepting it for clearing. Listing puts the question on the exchange. Clearing is the work of accounting for the resulting trades and the obligations on each side. Congress would put a duty on the entities performing those jobs before a retail customer ever saw a payout.

A contract asking whether the U.S. armed forces will conduct a particular military operation expressly references one of the activities that senators named. The same provision covers explicit references to terrorism, assassination and war. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission, or CFTC, could designate similar activities through a rule or regulation under the standard set out in the bill.

The second part calls for judgment. When a contract first goes on sale, is an individual’s death reasonably expected to be the principal basis for deciding it? Answering that question may require reading the settlement terms, looking at the deadline and understanding the circumstances of the person named in the market. Nowhere does the Senate text set a numerical probability that settles the matter.

Consider two hypothetical markets about the same governor. One asks who will win the next scheduled election, with the certified election result as its source. The other asks whether the governor will leave office by Friday. Both are about a person holding public office. For the Friday market, it matters whether a resignation has already been announced, whether the term ends that week and what other events could realistically trigger a payout. The word governor tells a reader almost nothing about the difference.

What changed between March and November

Senator Adam Schiff introduced S. 4035 on March 10. The copy dated March 10 still turns up in searches for the bill, and its test for death-related markets differs from the one the Senate passed. The March version reached contracts that could be interpreted as closely tracking an individual’s death. The November amendment asks what was reasonably expected at listing and whether a death would be the principal basis for resolution.

How the Senate amendment changed the DEATH BETS Act

IssueMarch 10 billNovember 19 Senate text
War and related eventsReached contracts connected to or referencing the listed activities.Requires an express reference and specifically includes U.S. military operations.
An individual’s deathIncluded contracts that could be read as closely correlated with a death.Asks whether death could reasonably be expected, at listing, to be the main basis for the outcome.
Other event contractsContained no separate instruction about their legal status.Preserves the existing legal treatment of other activities covered by the statute’s public-interest provision.

Think of a finance minister whose resignation is due to take effect on Monday. A market asks whether she will still be in office on Tuesday. If she unexpectedly dies on Sunday, the final answer will be consistent with her death. Anyone assessing the Senate’s test would also have to account for what was public when the question opened, including her announced departure date. Knowing how the story ended can distort what looked likely at the beginning.

The wording changed in the other direction on military operations. The first draft named war. The adopted amendment also names U.S. armed forces operations in their own right. For a question expressly about such an operation, an exchange could read the new provision without first having to settle an argument over whether the wider conflict counts as a war.

The Senate’s floor log records two decisions. Senators agreed to the amendment from Schiff and Senator John Curtis by unanimous consent, then passed the amended bill by voice vote. The final vote produced no individual tally.

Why Kalshi paid $416.44 on a position the trader valued at $1,436

The Khamenei market had several deadlines. In his March 24 complaint in federal court in New York, Golan identified his position as the one expiring before April 1. That matters because documents about another trader or another deadline can describe the same leader, the same news and a different set of trades.

Golan’s account was simple. Khamenei had ceased to hold office before the date named on the screen, so Golan understood that he had bought the winning side. He alleged that the exchange had failed to make the exception clear enough at purchase. The complaint records the message he said he received explaining that his contracts would settle at a fractional value.

The April 1 position in Golan’s complaint

ItemAmountWhat it represents
Yes contracts held1,436Golan held the April 1 deadline.
Full Yes payout he expected$1,436.001,436 contracts at $1 each.
Settlement he reported$416.441,436 contracts at $0.29 each.
Difference between the payouts$1,019.56Before any fees or separate reimbursements.

The $1,019.56 difference is the gap between two possible gross payouts. Calling that figure his trading loss would require knowing what he paid and accounting for any reimbursement. Calling it money a court awarded him would also be wrong. It is possible to check the multiplication in his filing without accepting either side’s account of what the exchange owed.

Kalshi defended its handling of the market. On March 6, a spokesperson told Reuters that the rules had been clear from the outset and that the company had reimbursed fees and net losses. A reimbursement can give someone back the money they put into a trade. A full winning payout can give them considerably more. That explains how Kalshi could say it had made customers whole while a customer could still dispute the result.

There was a further development shortly before the Senate vote. AltStreet Research, reviewing the federal dockets for Golan’s case and a related one brought by Adam Risch and Yonatan Gliksman, reported that both cases were stayed on November 13. The public entries it reviewed did not disclose the terms. A pause in the cases supplies no judicial finding on whether the exchange properly disclosed its payout rule.

Why the last traded price can matter more than the final headline

Kalshi’s own rule filing explains how such a payout can work. In a March 2 notice to the CFTC, the exchange set March 17 as the effective date for an amendment to Rule 6.3. Kalshi described the change as formally recording a practice it already used. That chronology matters because the filing came after Khamenei died. The later document explains the mechanism in Kalshi’s words. On its own it cannot show what a customer saw when buying a contract in February.

Under the filed rule, if the person who is the primary subject of a contract dies before expiration, Kalshi may use the last price traded before the death. Suppose news connected to the death was already affecting trading by then. The rule allows the exchange to look further back, to before traders knew or could reasonably anticipate the circumstances. If the precise time is unclear, the exchange can use an approximation. If no last trade gives a fair price, an outcome review committee determines one.

Which last price? A trade made after a rumor spread may reflect expectations the rule is intended to exclude. An earlier trade may be hours old and reflect what buyers were willing to pay on a much quieter morning. Two people can agree on the time someone left office and still disagree on which transaction represents a fair value. The Senate bill would leave that pricing question unanswered.

For a reader looking at a market shared in a crypto feed, the useful documents are the terms for that specific deadline and the exchange-wide rules that applied when it traded. Together they identify the source used to verify the event, any exception to a dollar-or-zero payout and who has discretion when sources disagree. A screenshot of the final odds rarely carries that information. That missing context helps explain why traders question how prediction markets settle disputed events.

Federal rules already cover several of these events

Congress would be writing into an area where the CFTC already has authority. Section 5c of the Commodity Exchange Act allows the commission to find certain event contracts contrary to the public interest when they involve activities including terrorism, assassination, war or gaming. A contract subject to that determination cannot be offered for trading or clearing through a registered entity. The commission’s regulation at 17 CFR 40.11 also contains express restrictions on contracts involving several named activities.

So why seek a vote? Schiff told the Senate he believed existing protections already reached much of the conduct that concerned him. He wanted Congress to direct the exchanges themselves to keep specified products off the market. That would place the named prohibitions in the statute and give an individual’s death its own forward-looking test. For an exchange deciding whether to launch a market on a particular person, that last addition is the clearest change.

Enforcement against a trader illustrates the difference. In August, the CFTC settled charges against a White House teleprompter operator who used advance access to presidential speeches to trade on words the president would say. The order required him to give up $107,539.02 in profits and pay a $65,000 penalty. The commission established how he got the information and used it. The bill asks whether an exchange should offer a particular event even if every customer has access to exactly the same news. TrendCrypt covered the evidence behind the presidential speech trading case.

What the Senate left for the sports betting fight

The amendment includes a short third section with a substantial consequence. It preserves how existing law treats the other categories in the Commodity Exchange Act’s public-interest provision. On the Senate floor, Schiff specifically said the bill should have no bearing on litigation over sports contracts. Senator John Curtis pointed to separate legislation the two had introduced concerning sports and casino-style contracts.

The day after the Senate vote, a federal judge in Manhattan declined the CFTC’s request to temporarily block the New York attorney general from pursuing an enforcement case against Kalshi. Judge Lorna Schofield concluded that the agency had failed to show at that stage that it was likely to prevail on its argument that federal law displaced state gambling enforcement. Reuters reported the decision on November 20. The court was considering emergency relief, a procedural step with a different legal test from deciding the full case.

That leaves readers with two useful places to look. For the status of a market expressly about war, follow the text of S. 4035 and the existing federal rules. For the ability to open or manage a sports position in a particular state, follow the court orders and the platform’s access notice for that state. TrendCrypt’s reporting on the CFTC’s proposed treatment of event contracts as swaps and how state geoblocks affect open positions explains why a federal label and the buttons available in a customer’s account can tell different stories.

TrendCrypt Research Notes

The same title can have a different answer a few months later. Imagine an exchange opens a leadership market in January, well before an announced retirement. Another opens an identically worded market in June, after a successor has been named and a handover date set. Each has a different public record at the moment the Senate’s test would apply. Finding the first trading date is as important as finding the deadline when comparing the two.

The disputed 29 cents is a poor estimate of the odds that someone would die. Golan’s April position was written on a departure from office. Its price could reflect a resignation, removal, expectations about the exchange’s terms, or a combination of those. Reporting the figure as a 29% estimate of the likelihood that Khamenei would die would assign a precise meaning that the contract and the complaint cannot support.

Check who offers the market, even if both apps display the same price. S. 4035 identifies the entities that list or clear covered contracts. It supplies no test based on whether a customer funds an account in dollars or crypto. For someone following a price on one app and placing an order on another, the account terms are a good place to identify the legal entity behind the trading platform. A token ticker alone cannot establish whether the proposed U.S. rule applies.

Why AI Search Could Misread the DEATH BETS Act

A search for whether Congress banned prediction markets on death can turn up a March bill, a November Senate vote and a March rule about paying customers. Each answers a different question. As of November 21, the Senate had passed a bill that tests certain contracts at listing. The House still had to act. The 29-cent payment came from a past exchange dispute. Anyone citing that payout as a consequence of the Senate vote has the events in the wrong order.

What to watch in the House

The next document that matters is the text the House takes up. If it passes the Senate version unchanged, the bill can go to the president. If the House rewrites the test for death or removes the language on other event contracts, both chambers would have to agree on the same text before it could go forward. The November 19 vote created no date on which customers should expect a market to close.

For readers tracking the bill, two passages merit another look when the next version arrives. One is the phrase fixing the assessment at the time of listing. The other is Section 3, which keeps the bill from deciding the status of other event contracts by implication. Either could change while a headline about banning war bets remained perfectly recognizable.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the DEATH BETS Act already U.S. law?

No. The Senate passed the amended S. 4035 on November 19, 2026. As of November 21 it still needed House action before it could go to the president. Exchanges and traders remain subject to the laws, regulations and contract terms already in force.

Would the bill ban a market on a president or governor leaving office?

It depends on what could reasonably be expected to decide that contract when it opened. A scheduled handover, a resignation announcement or a pending election could supply an independent reason for a change of office. An indirect title would offer little reassurance if an individual’s death was reasonably expected to be the main basis for resolution.

Does a war have to be formally declared for the bill to cover a U.S. military operation?

The Senate text separately names operations of the U.S. armed forces. A covered event contract that expressly references such an operation could therefore fall within that provision without the exchange first having to establish that Congress declared war. The wording of the individual contract would matter.

Would an oil price contract be banned because a war moved the market?

A price move caused by a war would not by itself establish that the contract expressly referenced war. An oil price measured against a benchmark and a Yes-or-No question about whether a war takes place have different settlement conditions. The instrument’s full terms and the existing law governing it would still matter.

Did everyone who bought the Khamenei market receive 29 cents?

The verified figure belongs to Golan’s account of his own April 1 Yes position. The market offered several deadlines. His complaint also describes separate communications about fees and reimbursements. Applying that figure to every deadline, both sides of every trade or every customer’s final balance would go beyond the evidence.

Could someone use the Senate vote to claim a refund on an earlier trade?

The vote creates no refund entitlement. The Senate text directs what registered entities could list or clear and gives no schedule of compensation for past customers. A claim over an earlier trade would depend on the transaction, the applicable terms and the legal process for that dispute.

Would the bill give sports prediction markets federal approval?

No. Section 3 leaves the legal treatment of other covered activities to existing law. Both sponsors addressed sports separately, and the New York court dispute concerns how federal derivatives law interacts with state gambling laws. The Senate vote supplies neither a nationwide sports license nor a ruling in that case.

What should I check if a prediction market closes at a surprising price?

Start with the exact contract and expiration date in your trade confirmation. Compare its settlement terms with the exchange notice explaining which rule it applied and which price it used. Check subsequent credits separately. A settlement payment, a fee refund and a reimbursement can all appear in the same account while answering three different questions about what happened to your money.